The American Nightmare

In Here We Are, Aarti Shahani tells the story of her wrongfully jailed father and uncle, and explores the ugly underbelly of the American dream.

The American Nightmare Large
The American Nightmare (Abhilash Baddha for The Juggernaut)

Meghna Rao


January 10, 2020


6 min

For all of its sweeping portrayals, the American dream is little more than a favorable statistical turn. A lottery system grants high-skilled workers H-1Bs and temporary stays in the U.S.; a résumé placed in front of the right person might shunt someone of the working class into a job with a six-figure salary. America is portrayed as a grand equalizer — any individual with a penny in one’s pocket and a dream in one’s head has a chance at winning a life that will provide economic success and happiness.

But like all bets, especially ones as disproportionately small and structurally unequal as the American dream, there are those who don’t win, who enter the country with the same hope, courage, and hard work as their counterparts, and face the American nightmare. 

They aren’t all fated to miserable lives. A rare group of these people, Aarti Shahani told me, become like her — statistical anomalies. In her memoir Here We Are: American Dreams and American Nightmares, Shahani details the wrongful imprisonment of her father and uncle, the uphill battles faced by her Indian immigrant, working-class, green card-holding family, and her fight to prove their worth. 

Join today to read the full story.


Already a subscriber? Log in