When Sima Mehta was 5, she glanced out from her balcony only to see a child about her own age playing with a broken tire in the slums below her apartment. “That kid looked at me, and I picked up one of the toys, which was lying next to me, and I threw it to that child,” Mehta, now 57, recalled. Then, more children started to appear. So Mehta reached into her toy bucket, and began hurling down a cricket bat, toy trains, and even umbrellas and notebooks.
But her mother was less than enthused, rewarding this display with a “hard slap,” she said. “I grew up to be an aggressive person myself,” Mehta reflected. “That was the only way I could survive.”
For as long as we can remember, we’ve debated the role of parenting in a child’s development: is it nature, and thus unchangeable, or nurture? But as many South Asian families become more successful, they’re grappling with a new frontier. They worked hard so they could make their kids’ lives easier. But in doing so, are we removing necessary friction and raising a new class of, well, entitled kids? We delved into the research and spoke to experts to find out.